A N Y Pizza House
3850 N Atlantic Ave, Cocoa Beach, FL, 32931
A N Y Pizza House Menu
Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.
Visit below restaurant in Cocoa Beach for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Cocoa Beach for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Cocoa Beach for healthy meals suggestion.
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
-
Address :
3850 N Atlantic Ave
Cocoa Beach, FL, 32931 - Phone (321) 868-7177
- Website https://mackinslice.com/
- Click To Get Directions
Opening Hours
Sorry, Store hours have not been updated. If you are the owner of this restaurants. Please update the store hours.
Specialities
- Takes Reservations : No
Delivery : Yes
Take-out : Yes
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Good For : Lunch
Parking : Private Lot
Bike Parking : Yes
Good for Kids : Yes
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Casual
Noise Level : Average
Alcohol : Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating : No
Wi-Fi : No
Has TV : Yes
Waiter Service : Yes
Caters : Yes
Categories
Pizza
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES
Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online
Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.
Matthew P.
OMG THIS PLACE ROCKED!!!!!!!!!! Gluten free pizza, Huge portions, massive (iceberg free) salads! Amazing service and fricken awesome FOOD! GO HERE NOW!!!!
(5)Chriscoral A.
This place is ok SOMETIMES.. It has poor consistency. Sometime pizza is ok sometimes it is horrible. We waited over an hour for a cold burnt pizza. My wife ordered a shrimp scampi pizza. We where told it was 27 dollars because it is expensive to make. When we got the pizza it was a burnt cold normal cheese pizza with shrimp on top. Maybe this itialian restaurant has no idea what scampi is. never order the meatball parm sub it's horrible.
(2)Robert B.
The pizza and house salad here are among the best in the area, but the consistency is just not there. I never quite know how the food is going to come out. The pizza is usually over cheesed. Sometimes there is the perfect amount of sauce, and sometimes not. I get that it's food made by people (not machines) so some variability is to be expected, but it's hard to get a baseline and make adjustments when ordering. But when it's good...it's soo good. Next up is the service. This restaurant frustrates me every time I walk in the door. There is a sign that says "wait here to be seated", but there's no hostess. No one ever directs me to a table, or takes my name or anything. I end up standing awkwardly in the small entrance area trying to figure out who I can get service from while dodging incoming and outgoing take-out patrons. It sucks. There's usually a person working a cash register near the bar taking to-go orders, but they won't seat people. If you walk up to this person you'll get frustrated looks from people waiting in line to place a to-go order because they think you are cutting in front of them. My wife and I usually try and avoid this problem by sitting at the bar area, but it's often too crowded to get a table. I've had great service from the bar every time I can actually get a seat there. The regular seating area is extremely lackluster. It's kind of dingy and worn, and there is zero atmosphere, especially with the ugly fluorescent lights. I get that it's a pizza joint and not some fancy restaurant, but I'm generally turned off by the environment. Even though I love the food here, I'm pretty much to the point where I'd rather not eat here unless I can get a seat at the bar. This place needs a makeover inside, and a good review of their service approach.
(3)Keelan P.
My FAVORITE pizza place in Cocoa. They have Gluten Free pizza and pasta. Hands down, the BEST Gluten Free pizza I've had anywhere. And the rest of my family, who CAN eat Gluten, tells me the normal pizza is amazing as well. They have it by the slice too... The biggest slices I've seen! Stromboli and calzones are awesome too ( I've heard ). This is a must visit place for me any time I'm in Cocoa.
(5)Nancy M.
Good, good, good! 1 large pizza with Pepperoni, 1/2 green pepper, 1/2 onion, 20 hot crispy wings, 2 sodas, 2 teas $45. The pizza was saucy, cheesy, & the peppers fresh! The service was on point! Quick, non intrusive & like a ninja..... Silent & effective . We walked over from our hotel at Wakulla. Soo good! Give it a try when you are on this side of Florida.
(5)Felix R.
While we were on vacation, we stopped at A N Y Pizza house to eat after being all day in the beach. We were there around 3, the place was pretty much empty. Service was quick, attentive, helpful. We ordered the small size pizza, as one of the other reviews wrote, too much cheese... but was good but you felt like you are eating a bomb. We also ordered the calamari and bbq wings, that were ok for a pizza place. The 2 tables next to us, ordered the largest pizza they have. It is HUGE, GIANT... You need to be very hungry to be able to eat that.
(4)Alexander K.
I wish it were possible to give a restaurant 6 stars. I'm updating this after they screwed up my order. I actually went to the restaurant at 10:00pm with my uneaten pizza. Well the owner's son, Travis, did a fantastic job of taking care of me and fixing the situation. 2 awesome pizzas. One for me and my girlfriend. A free beer for my want and just an overall positive experience. Will be ordering from them from now on. BTW, the pizzas were really good, too.
(5)Mitch L.
Oh my goodness!!! I wish they were on the West Coast of FL!! Their slices are just like you'd get in lower Manhattan. In other words they're huge!! I felt like I was in NYC. Hence the name ANY Pizza :) had garlic knots too. Could have been browned a bit more but very tasty. Alex my server was so nice and chatty and from NJ like me!! I will be back after the next rocket launch.
(5)Miguel A.
I went there the other night, was planning on getting a pizza, but changed my mind and got a eggplant parmesan. It was pretty good. So today I went back to get a 16" NY style pizza. Didn't look like any NY style pizza I ever seen, didn't taste like any NY pizza I ever had and I don't think I will ever go back for another pizza!!! I will go back and try some of the other menu items, just not the pizza...
(1)Brian T.
The Italian pizza pie was great! Service was good too! I went at an off time and had a great meal and cheap!
(4)Peggy O.
Ordered delivery and they came right to the room. Nice touch. Great pizza, fresh with generous toppings. Highly recommend the house salad. It was spring mix lettuce with very fresh veggies. Generous portions. Good experience. Would order again.
(4)N M.
Horrible. Went there with my husband as we thought it looked like a good place. There were leaks in the ceiling, the floor was filthy... We should have left. The waiter was nice enough, but the food? Disgusting. If you want pizza you're actually better off getting a frozen one from the grocery store.
(1)Bill C.
Wow. HUGE servings. I'm a big guy with a big appetite, and this place still had big servings. We came here for a late lunch and the place was less about a third full, but most of the tables were still dirty. Ok, things were busy at the lunch rush, so I can understand if it takes a while to clean the tables. Our waiter came by and took our order, but it seemed that he disappeared for a while. After a short wait our food came out. As I mentioned before, the portions are huge. Be prepared to bring leftovers home. The quality of the food was good and we enjoyed our meal. If the place had been a little cleaner, and the servers a little more attentive, this place would be a solid 4 star. Like I said, this was an interesting place, so I'd be willing to try it again.
(3)Shelby K.
We were told to go to this place by a couple friends and we were pretty disapointed. The service wasnt very good. Tables were not really clean. We got two greek salads. They were pretty good. The dressing was made in house and it waa great ill give them that. We then ordered the 18 inch margherita pizza. The toppings didnt have much flavor and the crust was too thick and pretty hard. Dont plan on being back. Papa vitos is down the road. Youll find me there for real deal pizza.
(2)Michele B.
My co-worker is a big pizza fan so we decided to give ANY Pizza house a try for dinner last night since it has so many good yelp reviews. We seated ourselves and were greeted in no time by our waitress Alex. She was very personable and attentive, really great! I opted for the chicken Parmesan which comes with a salad and garlic knots, plus a side of pasta. My coworker was going to go for 2 slices of pizza until the waitress pointed out how large a slice was, HUGE. Bigger than your head! He decided to start with one, very sound advice from the waitress. The house salad was pretty simple, mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumber and onions, but the creamy vinaigrette was delicious! Best part of the salad. With my meal came three HUGE garlic knots, larger than my fist! The garlic knots are served warm with a side of marinara sauce. The chicken Parmesan exceeded my expectations. The side pasta was nothing special but I ate every bite of my chicken, tasty! My co-worker who can normally eat half a pizza could only manage the one gargantuan slice, which is bargain priced at $2.50. His entire meal only ended up being $5! What a steal! The restaurant itself is nothing fancy, what you would expect from a pizza place but the food was surprisingly good!
(4)Shannon P.
Coming back for the second time on our vacation. Go early cause it's so good it will be crowded. If you are looking for authentic pizza then look no farther.
(5)Steve M.
The downside: perhaps I caught them on a bad night, but the server was undertrained as dishes went uncleared, empty drinks unfilled and the salad came out with the entrées. The upside: the salad was tasty and fresh and the pizza was one of the best I've ever had. I'll return the next time I visit CB but will insist on having another server.
(4)Ellyn B.
Wonderful eggplant parm and strombolli too! We come here every time we come to Cocoa Beach.
(5)Erik F.
Very good pizza. Try it. This was a great late night stop for carryout pizza in the Cocoa Beach area. We arrived near their closing time and asked if it was too late to order carryout. They replied "no" and were more than willing to cook us a great pizza. They also gave us napkins, paper plates and plastic utensils since we were taking the pizza and bread sticks back to our hotel room. Once we returned to our room and dived into the pizza and bread sticks, we realized what a fantastic meal we were eating. The crust was just crispy enough while the cheese, sauce and meats were cooked to perfection. We don't have any complaints about the food or service. It is well worth the visit. Very recommended.
(5)Rene F.
We were eating late once again and decided to get the pizza as carry out. We walked in and placed our order with no issues. The smells from the kitchen were amazing. We ordered a pizza that was all meats. Not the healthiest choice but it was delicious. Their small pizza was 16 inches and with just 2 of us we had leftovers. No problem since we had a mini fridge and microwave at our resort. The restaurant gave us paper plates and plastic ware. The pizza was so good we ate the leftovers for breakfast the next day! This will definitely be a repeat visit on our next trip to Cocoa Beach. We may even dine in and try other things that were on the menu!
(4)Kelly M.
Kids loved the garlic knots and the pizzas came out quickly and were really good. We found this spot through a gluten free restaurant listing. Their gf crust was good. Very friendly server.
(4)Paige B.
The food here was great! However the atmosphere was awkward, as everyone seemed super quiet and tired. We had a really sweet server who was a funny guy, but all the other servers seemed like walking zombies. I think with a more positive staff and happier atmosphere, this place would be a 5 star rating.
(4)Jennifer M.
We ate lunch at the Cocoa Beach location on an unfortunately and suddenly very rainy day in July. We'd intended to picnic at the beach but instead found ourselves looking for indoor dining. We were all a little sunburned, a whole lot annoyed at mother nature and above all, starving. So, six cranky non-beach-goers went to A.N.Y. Pizza. We left considerably happier! For a very fair $66 (plus tip for our excellent server) we had drinks, an appetizer and delicious, gigantic portions of tasty pizza. One group shared the 18" supreme and declared it the best, most loaded pizza with the most flavorful sauce they'd had. The rest of us shared the 18" Sheepshead Bay pie, loaded with clams, shrimp and scallops that they'd marinated in scampi sauce. It was unbelievable! There was enough cheese for two pizzas, the sauce was fantastic and the seafood divine. We're going back for dinner, no kidding. Bring on the rain! We're good!
(5)Katrina S.
My boyfriend and I stopped in Cocoa Beach for the night on our way back to Jacksonville Beach. We originally planned to go out for a fancy dinner, but decided to just get delivery to our room and we are thrilled that we did. I just devoured the most gargantuous calzone I've ever seen in my life. It was absolutely divine! We also ordered 10 hot wings and an antipasto salad. The wings? They were insanely delicious!! They were definitely the best wings I've ever had. The salad was yummy delicious also, and the portion was enough to feed me, my boyfriend, and the entire hotel staff. Needless to say, N.Y. Pizza House will be part of a new tradition when we visit Cocoa Beach!!!! Loved it!!!!!!!
(5)Scott D.
Yummy! This is one of the best pizza places I had. 26in. Pizza was on the table. Everything was big portions Great waitress - thx Alex!
(5)Cyndee R.
The service was slow. They were short handed. But the server was very upbeat and friendly and she was really good at multitasking the whole place. They have a gluten free menu which includes a pizza, and some soups, salads, and pasta dishes. They prepare, serve, and wash their gluten free food and dishes away from gluten. The single slices are HUGE! Prices are pretty affordable too.
(4)Tracy H.
The pizza was delicious and the waitstaff was super friendly and fun! Would definitely come back!
(5)Libby V.
We had spaghetti with meatballs and lasagne, Cesar salad came with both entrees. The meatballs tasted like round over cooked hamburger meat, tasteless, the pasta was bland, not cooked in salted water. The lasagne was so over baked with too much cheese and it was hard to find the actual lasagne noodles. It was like eating cheap melted mozzarella with a layer of raw tasting sauce and ricotta in the middle. The Cesar salad was huge and the obvious bottled dressing was decent. The garlic knots where too garlicky with chunks of garlic in each bite. Overpriced, sub par, tourist food. I guess I should have tried the pizza. I won't be back. Service was average and our waitress was quirky, but nice. Again $29 for 2 subpar entrees, I should have gone to Carrabas or Olive Garden.
(2)Rob W.
The Pizza is pretty good here. You can dine in, and they also do a Booming carry out and delivery business. They have gluten free Pizza here if you want that. One of the most impressive things here were the 26" Pizzas, absolutely huge. The Pizza on a tray was almost scary looking. One slice from the monster pie is a meal in itself. The prices are extremely reasonable here also.
(4)Sherry H.
The pizza was excellent the cannoli was delicious and our waitress Alex was the best.
(4)Chris P.
This place is a dump!!! Service was slow, everything was dirty, the dishes were dirty, the waitresses were complaining... We should have left right there. We stuck it out and now my daughter is sick from the food. The tables and chairs were uneven, paint was peeling from the walls. The food was horrible.... Even the salads were Crap!!! I can keep going on and on!!! Avoid this place at all costs... If you go the good thing is theirs a Pharmacy down the road to get some Tums for your stomach. Plus the bathroom was a disaster!!!!!
(1)Lillian M.
Hands down the best pizza and Italian food we've had down here. Creamy balsamic dressing could be sold in stores. Love this place.
(5)Betty F.
So happy they have GF pasta. The meat sauce needed a little seasoning but otherwise I am one satisfied girl!
(3)Ricky B.
Stopped by for a quick dinner our last night in cocoa beach. The waiter explained that the pizza slices were "the size of one of the menu panels" which was surprisingly an understatement!!! The slices are HUGE! I had the meat and my girlfriend had the cheese, and it was very delicious! Their meatballs as a pizza topping were absolutely yummy!!! The best part is that i spent under $10 (without tip of course) for a LOT of pizza! Nothing really bad to say except it was very dark inside. However it didn't matter to me. Took me a couple drive by's to realize it is called A N.Y. And not ANY pizza :) Anyways delicious pizza, friendly staff, and great pricing. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
(5)Joe R.
First time ordering from this restaurant after reading good reviews and to be honest the one start that I'm giving them is because the slice of pizza was ok. The pepperoni roll and the cheese calzone I order it was terrible, undercooked and the chicken tasted raw. I'm from NY and I believe that this place doesn't deserve to carry NY name in its establishment name. I will never order from here again nor would I recommended to anyone and on top of that they even forgot my 2 liter soda.
(1)Leslie S.
The antipasto salad is big enough for three people. The slice of pizza was bigger than my head and had fresh veggies. The only negative was that the service was slower than molasses.
(3)Todd P.
I saw the menu online and the "Meat Pizza" caught my attention. This is much more than a pizza house. I ordered takeout and it was ready before the Nationals and the Cubs played one full inning. This was the freshest pizza I've ever eaten. I definitely recommend this. Even the parmesan cheese what freshly grated. This was my first time visiting and I'll definitely be back. There's a lot more on the menu than pizza too.
(5)James P.
Got two massive calzones and a pitcher of beer for a late Sunday night dinner. Although it said they closed at 9pm, we got there at 8:45, were greeted, and sat with no problems. People actually kept coming in way after 9, too. Good calzones, good beer, good prices. A kid next to us got the "mackin'" slice. The one slice is the size of an entire frozen pizza. Awesome.
(4)Shawn B.
The food was delicious! That being said, the wait was horrible and the service was sub par. We called ahead and made reservations. People in our party waited for 20 minutes at the "Please Wait Here To Be Seated" sign without even being acknowledged by the staff. Several left in frustration. Once we were served, the waiter messed up the order but did give us one of our slices of pizza to make up for it. The seating debacle was the real issue here. If I were a bigger party, I would think twice and would definitely call ahead.
(2)Amber P.
Pizzas are huge and made to order quickly. They don't skimp on the serving sizes or on the ingredient portions.
(4)Luke M.
We ate here while staying literally across the street at the Wakulla Suites. When I asked the gentlemen behind the counter at Wakulla where a good pizza place was, he said A N Y and added not to try anywhere else. He was right! We got our food to go so this review is based solely on our interaction with the girl behind the counter and our food once we got it back to hotel. Staff was very friendly - we picked up at 8 pm on a Friday night and the restaurant was pretty busy. They had a ton of people working there but it wasn't too chaotic. We ordered the mozzarella dollars, bruschetta, and a large (16") white pizza. The breading on the dollars was awesome - very good overall. The bruschetta was also pretty good. It wasn't out of this world but it was still something we'd both eat again. The pizza was excellent, with just the right amount of toppings to keep it balanced. We got a few sides of their marinara sauce and it was equally as good. Overall a big success for us and we would certainly eat there again if we were in the area and wanted pizza or Italian apps, etc.
(4)Miss K.
We started off with the 10 piece wings, they let us split it up--5 with teriyaki and 5 medium. Wings were decent, had tons of seasoning with little breading. For "medium" the sauce was lacking kick so if you're a fan of spicy go with the hot sauce. The waitress was very, how do you say...bleh. Spoke in monotone and didn't seem to know much about the menu or at least what I was asking her. I opted for the plain slice which was good. Thin, HUGE. Some of he largest slices I've seen. Should have taken a picture since there aren't any here to reference. My boyfriend and mom decided on the pizza on focaccia bread pizza which was about 3" thick. They both seemed to expect something else. I thought it would be less thick too from previous sandwich experience. All in all the food was three stars and so was the service. The guy behind us seemed to love the soup he had so maybe we just ordered the wrong thing so I can't say I would never return. It's just one of those places that has SO many perfect reviews it makes me think that either 1, I should have ordered something else or 2, that this is one of those YELP pages that are riddled with fake reviews if that's even possible. Wouldn't be the first time I took a chance on a restaurant solely based on their YELP content and didn't live up to expectations. What did you think?
(3)Holly S.
We came here after reading the good reviews... The pizza slices are huge don't get me wrong.. Price aren't bad. When it comes to the taste of the pizza, little Caesar's has them beat. The pizza was soggy, and left an awful taste in my mouth for the rest of the day. The restaurant had these fans that blow your napkins and anything else lying down everywhere... Def not NY style pizza or anywhere close to that... Save your time and money......
(1)Dianna T.
Favorite place on A1A! I make a trip down to Cocoa Beach annually and this is one of the first places I stop in to chow down. Their mussels in lemon pesto sauce are outstanding. Their pizza by the slice is awesome and so big you could make two meals out of it. And my oh my it is delish! The homemade balsamic vinaigrette is out of sight, eye popping great! Love the friendly service, quiet atmosphere - all-around a superb meal and place!
(5)Daniel K.
I ordered 20 wings last night while I was at work so I got it delivered, the time when I placed the order was at 6:25. My food arrived at 8:00. The kid apologized but didn't mean anything cause our food was cold and didn't offer anything for our trouble. I'll give this place one more try sometime.
(2)I V.
Friendly service, and GREAT FOOD! After a long day of traveling.....I found a great place in walking distance from my hotel to eat at. I recommend the wings and pizza. Yum!! I ordered medium wings. In my opinion most places make there wings with to much vinegar for me. But wow, these wings were great. They had just the right amount of vinegar, spice, and awesome flavor....I could of probably just ate wings for dinner. But we also ordered a pizza, too. We ordered a pizza with jalapeños, and sasuage. The pizza was very fresh! I loved everything about this pizza. Great dough, Great pizza sauce, and Great ingredients! Glad I found this place during my short stay in cocoa beach. Our waitress was Alyssa and she was very friendly, and helpful!
(5)Robin W.
i Knew the pizza and pasta dish were excellent her, but tonight i ordered off the seafood entree's and it was delicious, fresh fish and shrimp..schrumpschious
(5)Steve B.
Pretty good pizza, HUGE slices. Mine could have been cooked another 90 seconds to perfection but no biggie. Get the calamari that's why you came to Florida right, to eat seafood?
(4)Chase J.
Excellent pizza, fast and friendly service. Some of the best I've had in a long time. Chicken Alfredo pizza was delicious. Would highly recommend checking this place out.
(5)Jared T.
Decent pizza. 16" fed two adults and one kid who were not necessarily starving. There's an AC fan that sounds like a helicopter though.
(4)Greg K.
Based on Yelp reviews chose this for a late dinner. Pizza was excellent - and one slice would have been enough. They are 12 " or more long and a 5 inch wedge. Lasagna was wonderful. We could have shared it. Service was excellent. Beer & wine available. I did not want pizza at the beach but now I would.
(4)Jessica R.
Our waitress was so funny and attentive and the gluten free pizza was crispy and delicious!
(4)Jeff A.
Excellent pizza. Mirrors New York style pizza. Call ahead seating is an option. Pizza has light sauce crispy crust thin.
(5)Kathy S.
I usually don't rate low for poor service, but tonight was an exception. Megan, our waitress, seemed less than interested in our table. While other tables seemed to merit her attention, me and my boyfriend seemed not to even be on her radar screen. She took our order, someone else brought our food, and only after our meals were mostly consumed did she walk by and we were able to ask after our salads. They came 10 minutes later with barely an acknowledgment. We had to ask for our bill. She proceeded to bring another table's food out and beverages to yet another table, then started taking their orders. At that point we gave up, walked to the front and was helped by another server. Food was just ok. My slice of pizza was good, very light on the sauce, but that may just be the style of pizza. Great crust, though. My boyfriend ordered the 4 course special. The oysters were runny and the mushroom ravioli was covered in some kind of funky beefy-mushroom gravy. Salad was good (abet late). If you try A N.Y. Pizza, I'd recommend you stick to the pizza, or maybe calzones. And hope you get better service.
(2)Steve B.
Have only ordered delivery. This is my favorite pizza place in the area. Have tried most of the pizza places in the past 2 months; A N Y is my go to place. Pizza is a matter of taste. I prefer their crust, more on the thin side and bit crispy. They know how to proportion toppings to maximize the taste of the pizza. Be forewarned, even their small pizza is huge! Discovered they deliver slices so tried that on the last ordered. Figured for 2 of us, 4 slices would be enough. Should have paid attention to the Yelp reviews. The 4 slices were larger than a large pizza from most any other place. Have now learned to just order one slice per person. Delivery has always been very quick, really nice people on the phone. If you're craving a really nice taste of pizza, this is top notch. If you're looking to pig out on pizza, you've found your place. These pizzas are not made of cheap ingredients, nor do they skimp on toppings. You can get a small (16 inch) with 3 toppings for around $16; that pizza will feed 4. I personally, don't like to get huge portions and have been overwhelmed by the size of the portions. I wish they had a "personal" size, like 10 inches but I guess that's what a slice is for. Really, the square inches of a slice are equal to a 10 inch pie. For me, the size of the portions just seem to boast and encourage over indulgence. I'll probably get over this negative feeling about too much once I get used to ordering one slice at a time. It's just a personal feeling, but the message I get from the pizza here is too much is a good thing and over doing food is to be encouraged. Other than the personal pet peeve, A N Y serves up a really good, well priced pizza.
(4)Mike M.
Is always a must stop place for us every trip to Coco Beach. Fair warning, the pizzas are huge. A small pizza easily feeds 2.
(5)Jennifer V.
Excellent pizza. Just like home. Salads were fresh, and they honor special requests. Like any good restaurant they get crowded but it's worth the wait.
(5)Brittany B.
I loved this place! I'm vacationing in cocoa beach from upstate ny and have been coming here for years. This was my first time here and it was awesome. I got the stuffed shells with meatballs and although it has a pizza joint feel the food was more Italian upscale restaurant. The pizzas and Strombolis were huge and I would definitely be interested in going back. Highly recommended!
(4)Leslie F.
Awesome giant slices of Pizza. Great, friendly service. Clean. Great for kids. Right across from Sheraton hotel. Ample parking.
(5)Jeremy W.
Very good pizza. Service was good. The wife and I had two kids in tow and all of left with smiles.
(5)C C.
WOW. I was in town vacationing and found this place using yelp. So glad my family and I stopped in. The place was loaded and we did have to wait about 20 minutes for a table (they really need to expand) but it was worth the wait. Great service, friendly staff, very awesome prices and HUGE portions of delicious food. Between everyone at our table we had ordered a Large pizza, a calzone and several individual custom slices. My calzone hung off the plate!! and was loaded with tons of toppings as previous reviewers stated. I ate and ate til I thought I might burst (also letting others take bites from it) and still had half the calzone to take home. Which later fed 2 of us lunch the next day! It's seriously huge. Trust me. Share this with someone else!! But either way -bottom line- if you're in the area - try this place, I'm pretty sure you'll enjoy it.
(5)Suzanne A.
Terrible dry pizza. Even the crust was unremarkable. Ordered the margarita pizza, a couple of dollops of fresh mozzarella, a few sprigs of fresh basil, a hint (I think) of garlic over a spread of tomato base, very sparce, and ordinary . We had maybe 10 pepperoni slices on the whole 18" pizza. We've had some great margarita pizzas, but this was at the bottom of our list. Expensive for a cheap knock-off. So disappointing, since the last time we visited it was a pleasant experience.
(1)Seth P.
Awesome and gluten free! Big gluten free menu to choose from and the pizza is spectacular!
(5)Derek F.
Our 6-year-old insisted on pizza after a round of mini-golf nearby and were it not for her we never would have eaten here. When we walked in the smell of urine coming from the men's bathroom was overwhelming. We had to move tables to be as far from the restroom as possible. It smelled as if someone had urinated in the mop bucket and then cleaned the restroom. That said, the calzone was pretty awesome and the cheese pizza was huge and lasted our daughter two meals. Eat outside unless your nose is plugged from a cold.
(2)Kimberly H.
My experience here was not the best. First, the service is terrible and short of professional in any sense. Second do NOT order by the slice. They simply add the desired toppings on ALREADY cooked pizza- which means none of the toppings are cooked and certainly not warm. I suppose if I ordered a whole pizza the toppings would have been cooked but really what is one more step... Just pop the slice in the oven! Anyway unless you like so-so pizza I would not recommend this place.... And For perspective: I worked in a pizza restaurant for 6 years.
(2)Marc W.
Arrived with my sons (age 7 and 4) at noon on Memorial Day to find about 1/3 of the tables occupied and another 1/3 of the tables unoccupied but full of dirty dishes. That should have been a hint to go elsewhere, but I didn't heed that warning. As a result, I found out that the service is very slow and inattentive, and the pizza isn't very good. The ingredients aren't fresh at all, and the crust wasn't cooked all the way through (despite a significant wait) so it was doughy and wet. The Greek salad was Greek only in that it had feta cheese on it; it had no other traditionally Greek ingredients, and the two choices of dressing were a "jalapeno ranch" and a "house vinaigrette." Having never seen a Greek jalapeno before, I opted for that. It wasn't horrible, but it was definitely not greek -- it was basically mayonnaise with thousand island and some sort of pepper flakes mixed in. Also, they had nothing to occupy children during the extended wait for our food, so bring your own if you must go there. Likewise, the children's menu was either non-existent or so obscure that I couldn't locate it. Yikes.
(1)Juliana R.
My family and I were looking for a nearby pizza place after spending the day at cocoa beach and decided to try this place after reading the reviews on yelp. We went in for takeout, and the girl who took our order seemed nice enough. There wasn't really a bar or anywhere to wait, but she did offer to sell us drinks if we wanted. It was pretty packed considering it was a Friday night. We got two 16 inch specialty pizzas (shrimp scampi and veggie lovers) and it was more than enough for three people. The pizzas were pretty tasty, although the shrimp scampi had more tomato sauce that one would expect. It also was a bit of wait- about half an hour- but I just assumed that was because they were making the pizzas fresh.
(4)Peter W.
We love this place! Every year we visit Florida we make it a point to eat at A NY Pizza House at least twice. And that's been over 10 years. Being from Chicago, I'm kind of funny about pizza, but we love this NY-style pizza. The white pizza is incredible. The pizza slices are HUGE. The pasta is really good with large portions. The calamari is some of the best I've ever had. The staff has always been friendly and fun. Next time we get down there I'm going to order a slice of pepperoni, an order of fries, and a pitcher of coke...
(5)Jake E.
Very good stromboli and cold beer. The pizza and calzones looked amazing. Very cool waitress and entire staff was friendly and funny. Worth a visit.
(4)Josh D.
Ordered a large cheese pizza and was very disappointed with the quality of the ingredients. Pizza was not very good. I will give them another try for dinner, but as far as pizza goes I will look elsewhere.
(3)Sean G.
As a native New Yorker, I didn't get the NY flavor I was expecting. Wings were decent, pizza is decent, calzones are wretched. Crunchy on the outside, cold in the middle. Classic case of trying to make too bag of a calzone so it doesn't cook right.
(3)Mike P.
As Authentic as it gets! We ordered 2 giant slices, egg plant parm dinner, and a chicken parm dinner. We loved it all! Best pie slices I've had in Florida! When in Cocoa Beach, this place is a must hit!
(5)Susan L.
I didn't read any reviews before going here but just read Kevin's review and mine will read so similar only by coincidence. I was in Walgreens in Cocoa Beach craving pizza and we asked a woman who worked there where there was a good place. I only wanted a slice not a whole pie also. First she said Pizza Hut - ugh! I mean c'mon I'm a native NYer also, so she suggested this place. So we went. Very friendly atmosphere and Kyle was our waiter. He's a Very pleasant and nice young man. My husband and I both ordered slices of sausage pizza and an order of wings. When the slices came I couldn't believe how big they were. I haven't had a slice that big since many years ago on the Boardwalk in Seaside NJ. Nice thin crust just the way we like it and tons of sausage. The crust was crispy and absolutely delicious. The wings came out piping hot and my husband really enjoyed them. We have now lived in FL a few years and this is honestly the best pizza I have ever had in this State. We enjoy visiting cocoa beach on weekends and I know for sure that we will always plan to eat here when we come. So happy to have found it and now we are very much looking forward to try other Italian classics when we come back. If you are a NY PIZZA lover this is the place for you. To put it in perspective just a month or so the Orlando Sentinel published their 100 best restaurants list which they do annually based on reader votes over several weeks. I couldn't believe it when I read that the winner for Best Pizza was Pizza Hut!!! Gimme a break! Skip that and get yourself over to A NY Pizza House if you are in the Cocoa Beach area. You will be glad you did!!
(5)Johnathan R.
Ordered delivery one gluten. It was just ok. The other one was suppose to be half pepperoni and half cheese. The pepperoni was missing. The delivery guy didn't have any change and the pizza was cold.
(3)Todd P.
Huge portions at a great price. Very friendly service. We got 3 26" pizzas to feed 14 people. We could only finish 1-1/2 of them so we'll be eating pizza for a week. Only reason I'm giving 4 instead of 5 stars is because I like my crust cooked more and on one of the few cold days we have here it was freezing inside. I would recommend if you order the 26" pies to ask them to cut them in twice as many pieces.
(4)Bridget P.
Pizza was delicious and flavorful!! You get a lot of food for the price. Can't wait to go again soon. Must try if you're in the area.
(4)Kelli T.
Good pizza. Good size. The toppings were fresh and they were generous with the cheese. Great thin crust with thicker, bready edge. Sauce was slightly sweet for my taste, but excellent otherwise. And the kids liked it too.
(4)Jennie R.
Super amazing! I read on here that the service was slow and they were right. But on the other hand they were beyond busy with eat in customers and take out. Needless to say that it was definitely worth the wait. The food was amazing! The portion sizes are huge! My one little slice of pizza will last me at least two meals! Got to take a visit to A N.Y. pizza
(5)Micah P.
From the outside, you may not know what to expect from this restaurant, but great food is inside! I was on a cruise on the Carnival Pride and one of our stops was Cape Canaveral, FL. We took the "Cocoa Beach Shuttle" and we didn't find very many places to go within walking distance. We found this place and the food was great! I recommend their bacon and potato soup and their strombolis and calzones are gigantic!! The staff is also very friendly and the food comes out fairly quickly.
(5)Ryan K.
Awesome pizza, especially the crust! The staff is very friendly even during the big dinner rush!
(5)Marc S.
Really good food! Staff is really friendly. Extremely large portions! Price is very reasonable! I highly recommend.
(5)Shannon And Jonathan M.
What a great find! The portions are plenty large enough and reasonably priced. Good for kids. Greek salad was large enough for 2 adults and 2 children.
(5)Fran P.
I think that this building finally has a restaurant that is going to make it! With a sister restaurant in Cocoa Beach, they have a track record. This week was their soft opening. No liquor license yet, but provided a complimentary glass of wine or beer. The entrees come with garlic knots and a side. My son had the lasagna and a salad. Generous portion and delicious! He had the side salad with the jalapeno ranch dressing which was delicious! In fact, it was so good that I even ordered a second dressing on the side for my antipasto salad. I'd already selected the creamy balsamic dressing that was also amazing! My salad was HUGE. Lots of meat and cheeses as well as marinaded vegetables. We took home enough left overs for a second meal! Our bill was just under $23! (Of course there was no charge for the wine this time!) If you are in the area, try this restaurant. Next time I am going to try the pizza if I can resist a repeat of that wonderful salad!
(5)Robert C.
This was a solid 4 star choice for beach pizza and $2:50 draft beer. The pizza was good and the beer was cold. One warning - this building is a converted fast food restaurant and seating inside is tight. It probably works for them since the place does a lot of takeout business. Avoid siitting at the tables next to the entrance, we had people and rude kids basically standing on top of us. Apparently a few of the adults were also taking a vacation from parenting
(4)Eric O.
Stopped with my family for something simple. They Appeared to be pretty busy, but we squeezed in a table. The help was very much on there game. Drinks were brought and refilled in a timely matter. We ordered a 18" pizza that was more like a 20" to 21". Crust was excellent. Garlic bread knots were very good also!!! Would definitely visit again!!!!!
(4)Janine B.
This place was so busy on a summer saturday. Good sign! We got the huge pizzas as a take out. Everyone loved them. THE pizza place at the beach!
(4)Susan W.
Really great slices cooked to order. Got mine to go, so I listened to the people in the kitchen talk while I waited. Plenty of good humor. Place has a good vibe. Pizza is delicious!
(5)Miguel R.
Everything you'd expect from a pizzeria. Great food and great service. I would definitely make this a common spot for me if I lived in the area.
(5)M P.
So many things on this menu are a MUST. You simply can't make a bad choice. Their ceasar dressing is incredible. Of course the pizza is great and a single slice is a good size/good value. Love this place! Wish they would open the drive thru window that came with the building. YUMMY!!! They deliver so order and enjoy.
(5)Barbara R.
Yummy. Fast delicious and friendly service. Pizza by the slice was perfect thing. Really hit the spot.
(4)